DIGITAL REACHMARKETING · ADVERTISING
A Website Teardown

Never do this on your website

Three mistakes quietly leaking your customers — and the dead-simple fix for each. No tech words. Promise.

By David Shane Perry · Digital Reach (Hawaii) · Updated June 2026 · ~7 min read

Most websites don’t lose customers in one big way. They lose them in three small ones: how it looks, whether Google can find it, and what you ask people to do. Fix all three and more of the visitors you already have quietly turn into customers. Here’s the wrong-vs-right for each, the numbers behind them, and a one-page checklist you can copy and keep.

The 1-page wrong-vs-right website checklistCopy it. Run your homepage against all three.

Look — how it loads & reads

✕
Don’t: make people wait, or crowd the page with competing stuff.
✓
Do: aim to load in ~1 second and show ONE clear thing first.

Find — whether Google sees you

✕
Don’t: break on phones, or ship blank / copycat page titles.
✓
Do: be mobile-friendly and give every page a clear, honest title (~60 characters).

Ask — what you request

✕
Don’t: pile on form fields and five competing buttons.
✓
Do: ask for the minimum (aim for ~3 fields) and give ONE clear button.

Below is the why behind each line — the mechanism, the receipts, and the exact move. Jump to Look, Find, or Ask.

Leak 1 — LookDon’t make people wait

People decide whether they trust your site in about 50 milliseconds — faster than a blink. That’s not a figure of speech: in a study by Lindgaard and colleagues, visitors formed stable visual-appeal judgments in 1/20th of a second (Lindgaard et al., 2006). Roughly 94% of those first impressions are design-related (Stanford research, widely cited). You don’t get a second one.

Then there’s speed. Google’s own research found that 53% of mobile visitors abandon a page that takes longer than three seconds to load (“The Need for Mobile Speed,” Google, 2016). And it compounds: when the experience is bad, around 88% of people don’t come back. A slow, cluttered page isn’t a small annoyance — it’s a closed door.

A slow page is a closed door. Most people never knock twice.

The fix

Make it fast and make it clear. Faster pages don’t just feel better — they sell better: shaving load time toward the one-second range can convert visitors into buyers materially better than a five-second page. Compress your images, cut the third-party scripts you don’t need, and lazy-load what’s below the fold. Then do the harder thing: pick ONE clear action for the page and remove everything competing with it. A homepage that asks for one thing beats a homepage that whispers ten.

Worked example. A local service business had a hero image weighing 4MB, an autoplay video, and three pop-ups firing on load — about 6 seconds to interactive on a phone. Swapping the hero for a compressed image, killing the video, and holding the pop-up until scroll dropped it under 2 seconds. Same content, same offer; far fewer people bouncing before the page even finished.

Leak 2 — FindDon’t hide from Google

More than 60% of web traffic now comes from phones, and Google indexes the mobile version of your site first (mobile-first indexing). If your pages are hard to use on a phone — tiny tap targets, text you have to pinch to read, content spilling off the screen — you’re not just annoying visitors, you’re handing Google a reason to rank you lower.

The other quiet killer is the page title. Your title tag is the headline Google shows in the results and the single strongest on-page signal of what a page is about. Leave it blank, let your CMS auto-generate “Home | Untitled,” or copy-paste the same title across every page, and you throw away your best shot at getting picked. Aim for a clear, honest title around 50–60 characters so it doesn’t get truncated.

No clear title? You’re invisible — even when you rank.

The fix

Help Google find you. Run your site through Google’s mobile-friendly check and fix what breaks. Then give every important page a unique, descriptive title that leads with the thing people actually search for — “Honolulu Plumber | Fast 24/7 Service” beats “Home.” Do that consistently and you climb toward page one, where nearly all the clicks live. The top organic result captures a wildly disproportionate share of clicks; positions on page two are, for most queries, a rounding error.

Worked example. A shop had every page titled with just its brand name and a layout that overflowed on mobile. Writing search-led titles for the top 10 pages and fixing the responsive breakpoints moved several terms from page three to the top of page one over a couple of months — no new content, just making the pages legible to phones and to Google.

Leak 3 — AskDon’t ask for too much

Every extra thing you ask for costs you customers. Every form field is a tiny decision; every competing button is a fork in the road. Pile on enough of them and people freeze and leave. The most famous example in the field: Expedia had one optional “Company” field on its checkout. People kept misreading it, entering the wrong address, and failing verification. Expedia deleted that single field and reportedly earned an extra $12 million a year (UX Movement). One field.

It’s not an outlier. Trimming a form from 7 fields to 3 commonly lifts conversions by 20–35% (Venture Harbour). The mechanism is simple: less to think about means more people finish. The same is true for choices — a page with one clear call-to-action beats a page with five buttons fighting for the click.

More boxes, more buttons, more thinking — fewer customers.

The fix

Ask for less. List every field on your most important form and ruthlessly cut anything you don’t truly need to take the next step — you can always ask for more later. Replace competing buttons with one obvious action. If you must collect more, break it into steps so each screen asks for a little. Less friction is the cheapest conversion lever you have, and it usually costs nothing but the courage to delete.

Worked example. A lead form asked for name, email, phone, company, job title, budget, and “how did you hear about us” before anyone could talk to a human. Cutting it to name, email, and one line about the project — three fields — and swapping four buttons for a single “Get my quote” roughly doubled completed submissions. The dropped fields became questions for the first reply instead.

Quick answers

What’s the single highest-impact fix?

For most small-business sites, it’s speed and clarity (Leak 1) — it affects bounce, trust, and rankings at once. If your site is already fast, the form (Leak 3) is usually the cheapest win, because cutting fields costs nothing.

How fast does my site really need to be?

Treat three seconds as the line in the sand on mobile (Google’s threshold for ~53% abandonment) and aim toward one to two seconds. Test on a real phone on cellular, not your office Wi-Fi.

How long should a page title be?

Around 50–60 characters so Google doesn’t cut it off. Lead with the search term, keep it honest, and make every page’s title unique.

How few form fields is too few?

Ask only for what you need to take the very next step — often just name, email, and one line of context. You can collect the rest in your first reply.

Want us to find the leaks for you?

We’ll run your site against all three — look, find, ask — and hand you the specific fixes, in plain English. No jargon, no pressure.

Get a free website teardown
  • Sources:
  • Lindgaard, G. et al. (2006). “Attention web designers: You have 50 milliseconds to make a good first impression!” Behaviour & Information Technology 25(2).
  • Stanford Web Credibility Research — first impressions are ~94% design-related (widely cited).
  • Google (2016). “The Need for Mobile Speed” — 53% of mobile visitors abandon after 3 seconds.
  • UX Movement — “The $12 Million Optional Form Field” (Expedia).
  • Venture Harbour — form-length studies (7→3 fields lifts conversions ~20–35%).

Like this content? Consider subscribing to get more. No spam, I promise.

By Categories: SEOComments Off on Never Do This On Your Website: 3 Mistakes (Wrong vs Right) + Free Checklist